Séminaire PhilBio
Nous aurons le plaisir d'accueillir : Fridolin Gross (Université de Bordeaux) qui interviendra sur le sujet suivant : Towards theory-free classifications in single-cell biology?
Résumé : The concept of cell type has recently become problematic among biologists, as evidenced by a series of programmatic articles proposing new ways to classify cells. Often, these articles call for a purely “data-driven” approach to classification, implying that traditional classifications are inadequate due to their reliance on background assumptions. New technologies, such as single-cell sequencing combined with sophisticated computational pipelines, are proposed as a basis for such “theory-free” classifications. However, there are fundamental problems with the ideal of theory-free classifications. Novel technologies are always situated within a history of epistemic iteration and thus adopt background assumptions from earlier methods. On the other hand, data generation and processing involve decisions, e.g. the choice of parameters, which are based on background knowledge if they are not to be arbitrary. But to argue against the theory-free ideal is not necessarily illuminating. Here, I consider the weaker version of a “theory-minimizing ideal.” I consider whether biologists should take a path that increasingly reduces dependence on background assumptions. Would this be desirable in view of the goals of the discipline, or would it be wiser to work on consolidating the background knowledge on which existing classifications are based?
Organisation : Claudia Gadaleta, Sandra Ranchon et Jeanne Trouvé
Contacts : claudia.gadaleta@univ-paris1.fr, sandra.ranchon@etu.univ-paris1.fr, jeanne.trouve@univ-paris1.fr